In August we explained what the assessment of noise and shadow flicker at wind farms currently requires in Chile: the Environmental Assessment Service (SEA) recommends the German technical guideline as its reference, with a maximum of 30 hours per year and 30 minutes per day in the worst-case astronomical scenario, and 8 hours per year in the real scenario. This article goes one step further: how to build the calculation so that it holds up during the assessment, and what to do when a receptor exceeds those values.

The reference is the SEA technical document Criterio de evaluación en el SEIA: efecto sombra intermitente en parques eólicos (SEIA assessment criterion: shadow flicker at wind farms, June 2021). It starts from a simple fact: Chile has no standard for this effect, so it is assessed as a risk to public health (Article 11(a) of Law No. 19,300), using international reference standards.

Two scenarios, two ways of looking at the receptor

The SEA criterion requires both scenarios of the German guideline to be presented, and each treats the receptor differently:

In both cases the receptor is assessed at a reference height of 2 m above ground. Sun positions below 3° above the horizon are not considered, and the study area extends to the distance at which a rotor blade still covers 20% of the solar disc.

Where the result is decided

Two models with the same turbines can give very different results depending on the assumptions. The ones that matter most:

What has to be submitted

According to the SEA criterion, the study must include:

  1. The turbine data sheet: hub height, rotor diameter and blade width.
  2. A clear description of the receptors within the area of influence: dwellings, but also bedrooms in hotels and hospitals, classrooms and offices. Terraces and balconies are protected from 6:00 to 22:00.
  3. A table per receptor with daily shadow duration, to a precision of 1 minute per day, and annual duration in hours.
  4. A map with shadow isolines, especially the 30-hour-per-year isoline.
  5. The software calculation report with all assumptions: minimum sun elevation, time step, monthly probability of sunshine, operating time, cut-in wind speed, contour lines, obstacles, eye height and grid resolution.
  6. A KMZ file with all the information, in UTM coordinates.

If a receptor exceeds the values

The SEA criterion distinguishes two cases:

One point worth keeping in mind from the design stage: the SEA does not accept natural or artificial barriers as a measure to address a significant impact, because they replace flickering shadow with permanent shade over the dwelling.

So when the model shows exceedances, the useful conversation is not how far the result can be lowered through assumptions, but which turbines will have shutdown, for which receptors and at what times. That decision belongs to the developer, and the study should give them the information to make it.

How we do it

We model shadow flicker with windPRO, covering both scenarios of the SEA criterion, with tables per receptor, isolines and KMZ, and we respond to the SEA’s observations on this effect during the assessment.

Is your wind farm in design, or has it received observations on shadow flicker? Book a 20-minute call: we will make a free preliminary assessment and you will receive a free technical proposal within 1 to 5 working days.

Nicolás Bastián Monarca
About the author
Nicolás Bastián Monarca
Head of Engineering · Acoustic Civil Engineer · MSc in Acoustics and Vibration

He leads Acústica Austral’s environmental noise and vibration studies for the SEIA across energy, port and infrastructure projects, and has contributed to reference work for Chile’s Ministry of the Environment.

Meet the team →

Free resources for your project

Guide to the D.S. N°14/2024 and the acoustic checklist for entering the SEIA, in PDF. We email them to you.

Get both resources